In the early days of Jewish Christian history, the Ebionites emerge as torchbearers of a unique viewpoint on the Apostle Paul, challenging established narratives that later became the bedrock of Catholic Orthodoxy.
Hyam Maccoby introduces a fascinating proposition, suggesting that Paul might have been a Hellenized Jewish convert whose background exposed him to the influences of Gnosticism and pagan mystery religions such as the Attis cult. Maccoby contends that these prevalent mystery religions in the Hellenistic world significantly shaped Paul’s mythological psychology.
The Ebionites, rejecting the Pauline Epistles, perceived Paul as an apostate from the law, and understanding their historical context is paramount to comprehending the depth of their opposition. Scholarsly consensus categorizes the Ebionites as a Jewish-Christian sect, some say the most authentic witness to the historical Jesus.
The Ebionites followed the Jewish traditions as well as regarding Jesus as a Prophet advocating for the end of Temple Sacrifices—a mere man born to Mary and Joseph, who was his physical father. They maintained fidelity to Jewish law, emphasizing practices such as dietary laws, circumcision, shabbat, the festivals, and other Jewish customs.
A pivotal tenet of Ebionite belief was their rejection of Pauline teachings, branding the Apostle as an apostate, and disagreeing with his view that Gentiles could be included without adherence to Jewish rituals of mikveh and circumcision. Scholars show a connection between the Ebionites and early Jerusalem leaders, namely—James, Peter, and John.
This sect is often viewed as a continuation of the original Jewish-Christian community in Jerusalem. Associated with a unique Hebrew Gospel, the “Ebionite Gospel,” fragments and references remain in early Christian writings. Simon, identified as the brother of James and Jesus, emerges as an early Ebionite leader, succeeding James in leading the Jerusalem Synagogue.
Additional facets of Ebionite practice include asceticism, which they adopted from the Essenes, abstaining from meat and wine, influenced by a rigorous interpretation of Jewish laws. Ebionite Christology, can be described as adoptionist, they posit that Jesus became a Prophet at his baptism, denouncing temple sacrifice—an ideology that influenced their dietary choices. There is evidence of interaction and influence from the Ebionites upon Rabbinic Judaism, potentially impacting the development of Rabbinic Jewish thought.
Ebionites, a sect within early Jewish Christianity, held a distinct perspective on Paul, rejecting his Epistles and viewing him as an “apostate from the law.” According to the accounts of Origen, they may have been linked to the “super-apostles,” influential Jewish Christian followers of Jesus who advocated for mandatory circumcision of converts, Paul sought to undermine their teachings in regions like Galatia, Corinth and elsewhere.
Epiphanius of Salamis, an early bishop, provides further insights into the Ebionite stance against Paul. They opposed him for propagating the idea that Gentile Christians were exempt from circumcision and adherence to the Law of Moses, labeling him an apostate. Some Ebionites even claimed that Paul, originally a Greek who converted to Judaism, apostatized after being rejected by the daughter of a high priest of Israel.
Within the broader context of Christian history, the concept of the Great Apostasy takes center stage. It characterizes the perception that mainstream Orthodox Catholicism deviated from the original faith established by Jesus and propagated by his twelve Apostles. The Ebionites see Paul’s writings as key factors in this apostasy, challenging the traditional narrative of his role in shaping early Christianity. That Apostasy was made to be the prominent thing.
In the Toledot Yeshu, the name Yeshu is interpreted by some to mean yimakh shemo, emphasizing its association with acts or behaviors perceived as leading Jews away from Judaism into minuth, commonly translated as “heresy” or “apostasy.” This historical perspective sheds light on the portrayal of Jesus in the Talmud and Jewish literature, namely that of Simon Magus, of whom many believe was either the Apostle Paul or one of his associates lead the apostasy.
The Ebionite view of Paul provides a compelling lens to reexamine his impact upon early Christian thought. Maccoby’s exploration of Paul’s hellenistic background, coupled with the Ebionite rejection of his teachings as Apostasy, adds to the historical understanding. As we unravel the intricate dynamics between Paul, the Ebionites, and the broader early Christian landscape, we gain a nuanced understanding of the influences shaped the theological underpinings that was used to later invent Christianity as we know it.
The Pulling the Thread Podcast 
Leave a comment